August 21, 2006

Dark clouds on the horizon.

Posted by apostropher

An article by bonddad at The Agonist argues that even if the Democrats take back Congress this fall, they will be facing an economy in shambles within six months, with no ability to pump money into it to help cushion the downturn.

Increased government spending is the standard method of ameliorating an economic downturn. However, the Republicans have seriously hampered this ability. Although they are claiming they will halve the deficit by 2009, total debt issuance from the Bureau of Public Debt tells a far different story:

In 2002, the total deficit was $157 billion. Yet total debt outstanding increased from $5.807 trillion to $6.228 trillion, or $421 billion.

In 2003, the total deficit was $377 billion, yet total debt outstanding increased from $6.228 trillion to $6.783 trillion, or $555 billion.

In 2004, the total deficit was $412 billion, yet total debt outstanding increased from $6.783 trillion to $7.379 trillion, or $596 billion.

In 2005, the total deficit was $318 billion, yet total debt outstanding increased from $7.379 trillion to $7.932 trillion or $553 billion.

The US has already issued $568 billion in new debt for fiscal 2006.

In other words, the amount of debt the US Treasury is issuing indicates THE DEFICIT IS NOT UNDER CONTROL IN ANY MEANINGFUL WAY.

Suppose a Democratic majority in the House wants to increase federal domestic spending to either stimulate the economy or mitigate the negative impact of an economic downturn. There isn't any money to do this. The debt/GDP ratio has increased from the upper 50s percent range to the lower 60's over the last 5 years. Currently international interest rate arbitrage is the only major factor preventing the currency traders from selling dollars because of fiscal mismanagement. However, the Federal Reserve is near the end of its interest rate increases while other central banks are increasing their respective rates (although the jury is still out on Japan's current policy direction). These two factors - the US halting its interest rate increases plus other countries increasing their interest rates - will make the dollar vulnerable. An increase in deficit spending will increase the possibility of a dollar sell-off because currency traders will wonder if the US will ever get its fiscal house in order. A dollar sell-off will increase inflationary import pressures, forcing the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates to protect the dollar. Increasing interest rates will slow the economy at a time while it needs economic stimulus.

Increasing the dollars vulnerability is the composition of international purchases of US Treasury debt. Over the last few years, foreign individuals are responsible for the bulk of US Treasury purchases; foreign official institutions (such as central banks) have backed away from the US Treasury market. Foreign central banks are less prone to sell assets in bulk; they are more likely to by "buy and hold" investors. Not so with individuals. If the investment isn't returning a certain amount each year, individuals will seek higher return elsewhere. Considering China, India and Russia are all growing faster than the US and have a far better international account position, moving assets to these countries is a strong possibility. In addition, all three of these countries will probably be willing to cut very beneficial deals for new foreign inflows. In short, an increase in deficit spending may spook foreign private money away from the US market, sending US market-based interest rates higher, adding to downward economic pressure.

There's quite a bit more at the link, if you can stomach it.

TrackBack
Comments
1

I agree that this is all bad news, but disagree that government spending is much help in ameliorating an economic downturn. Order created by government spending is an illusion.

That is like calling in a hurricane to fix up the mess caused by a spat of tornados.

The wild economy is like a tropical rainforest. The more central planning that is applied to the rainforest in attempts to turn it into a garden or a farm, the less productive it is at processing and transforming the energy input from the sun.

But this article is right in many ways. Uncle Sam can only debase the currency so much before foreign investors decide that he is no longer worth lending money to.

Posted by: Jonathan Carson at August 21, 2006 11:28 AM
2

In IdeologyLand, perhaps. But in the real world, where the federal government does play a major role in the economy, adding money to the economy does cushion economic downturns. This really isn't a debatable notion.

Posted by: apostropher at August 21, 2006 11:56 AM
3

Apostropher is right on here, as is the article.

But why should we be surprised? Isn't this the whole Republican master plan? To run the government into the ground while they're in charge, and then turn around and argue that government just doesn't work! Genius!

And it's actually happening. *shiver*

I, too, fear for the Democrats' ability to use government to make a difference once they retake Congress (either in '06 or '08).

Posted by: NCProsecutor at August 21, 2006 12:10 PM
4

they said the same thing when Clinton took over. The solution? Send the budget on course to be balanced. long term interest rates drop, and investment rises. Economic activity kicked off, and the budget that was supposed to ruin Clinton and the country ended up giving us 7 years of sustained economic growth anda budget surplus.

Differences? Gas prices and hemmorrhaging sucking chest wound in Iraq. At least one of those is fixable.

Posted by: DrFrankLives at August 21, 2006 11:44 PM
5

The Republicans are like kids in a candy store, and they don't want to leave. Bankrupting the country and flushing it down the tubes is not part of a master plan, although there certainly is plenty of rationalization that it's better that Republicans stay in power and mess things up rather than - shudder - Dems. Think venality and opportunism on the part of the Republican elite.

Posted by: PutzheadTom at August 22, 2006 06:15 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?