February 22, 2006

How much do you know about ice?

Posted by apostropher

Very little, it turns out. Even those who know the most about it don't really know that much. They can't even make complete sense of why it's slippery. And while that's an interesting enough discussion, I was more captured by how many types of water ice exist.

Besides the everyday ice that you slip on, there are about a dozen other forms, some of which experts suspect exist in the hot interior of Earth or on the surface of Pluto. Scientists expect to discover still more variations in the coming years. [...]

Water — H2O — seems to be a simple molecule: two hydrogen atoms connected to a central oxygen atom in a V-shape. In everyday ice, which scientists call Ice Ih, the water molecules line up in a hexagonal pattern; this is why snowflakes all have six-sided patterns. (The "h" stands for hexagonal. A variation called Ice Ic, found in ice crystals floating high up in the atmosphere, forms cubic crystals.)

The crystal structure of the ice is fairly loose — the reason that Ice Ih is less dense than liquid water — and the bonds that the hydrogen atoms form between water molecules, called hydrogen bonds, are weaker than most atomic bonds. At higher pressures, the usual hexagonal structure breaks down, and the bonds rearrange themselves in more compact, denser crystal structures, neatly labeled with Roman numerals: Ice II, Ice III, Ice IV and so on. Scientists have also discovered several forms of ice in which the water molecules are arranged randomly, as in glass.

At a pressure of about 30,000 pounds per square inch, Ice Ih turns into a different type of crystalline ice, Ice II. Ice II does not occur naturally on Earth. Even at the bottom of the thickest portions of the Antarctic ice cap, the weight of three miles of ice pushes down at only one-quarter of the pressure necessary to make Ice II. But planetary scientists expect that Ice II, and possibly some other variations, like Ice VI, exist inside icier bodies in the outer solar system, like the Jupiter moons Ganymede and Callisto.

With pressure high enough, the temperature need not even be cold for ice to form. [...] The scientists started considering what happens to tectonic plates after they are pushed back down into Earth's interior. At about 100 miles down, the temperature of these descending plates is 300 to 400 degrees — well above the boiling point of water at the surface — but cool compared with that of surrounding rocks. The pressure of 700,000 pounds per square inch at this depth, Dr. Bina and Dr. Navrotsky calculated, could be great enough to transform any water that was there into a solid phase known as Ice VII. No one knows whether ice can be found inside Earth, because no one has yet figured out a way to look 100 miles underground. Just as salt melts ice at the surface, other molecules mixing with the water could impede the freezing that Dr. Bina and Dr. Navrotsky have predicted.

Ice also changes form with dropping temperatures. In hexagonal ice, the usual form, the oxygen atoms are fixed in position, but the hydrogen bonds between water molecules are continually breaking and reattaching, tens of thousands of times a second. At temperatures cold enough — below minus 330 degrees — the hydrogen bonds freeze as well, and normal ice starts changing into Ice XI.

William B. McKinnon, a professor of earth and planetary sciences at Washington University in St. Louis, said that astronomers were probably already looking at Ice XI on the surface of Pluto and on the moons of Neptune and Uranus. But instruments currently are not sensitive enough to distinguish the slight differences among the ices. The most recently discovered form of ice, Ice XII, was found just a decade ago.

They expect there are more to come.

TrackBack
Comments
1

Don't forget Ice-9!

Posted by: Lex at February 22, 2006 11:01 AM
2

See the cat? See the cradle?

Posted by: Charles Watkins at February 22, 2006 12:04 PM
3

And yet they still can't get the funding to make Cool as Ice II.

Posted by: norbizness at February 22, 2006 12:28 PM
4

Water is the weirdest substance on earth. Which is scary considering how much goes into our bodies.

Posted by: John Johnson at February 22, 2006 01:51 PM
5

And let's not forget the many varieties of Italian ices.

Posted by: Gaijin Biker at February 22, 2006 09:50 PM
6

When my sister did a stint in Antartica, she reported that researchers there have developed a very stringent etiquette for what kind of ice can be put in what kind of drink.

Posted by: Jackmormon at February 28, 2006 11:47 AM
7

Ice Ih is not a crystal structure of the water molecule.
I discovered the crystal structure of a true water molecule though I was not a
scientist.

If the crystal is seen, a scientist all over the world becomes silent.

Crystal changed in law by pressure and temperature.
I would like you to be interested by all means.

Because only Japanese can be spoken, I'm sorry.

Posted by: Takashi Yamamoto at July 7, 2006 02:30 AM
8

I've been working in machine translation long enough that I find that comment endearing. (He may even be using my software.) I can even figure out from the translation what most of the original Japanese sentences were.

Just for the record, he's not implying that scientists will be frozen by ice-9 and rendered mute, nor is he saying that Japanese is the only language allowed to be spoken. It's hard to avoid this sort of thing with translation software when the original language is as vague as Japanese.

Posted by: Big Ben at July 9, 2006 08:21 PM
9

"vague" s/b "inscrutable"

Posted by: M/tch M/lls at July 9, 2006 10:20 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?